Strawberry and Grilled Goat Cheese Sandwich Recipe

Strawberry and Grilled Goat Cheese Sandwich recipe! This is an easy recipe to whip together for lunch or dinner. Use up those strawberries that have been sitting in the fridge!

It's been years since I've had a regular grilled cheese sandwich. Don't get me wrong I love grilled cheese, but as an adult I just don't feel right eating them anymore. I would feel guilty eating one now. As adults we are supposed to make better food choices and find ways to add healthy ingredients to our meals. Lucky for us the older we get, the more daring we become with food. I'm sure you can all list off at least 5 foods that you love now as an adult, but hated as a kid. 

When I was a kid, if someone tried to serve me this Strawberry & Grilled Goat Cheese Sandwich, I would have run far, far away. Strawberries are not supposed to be grilled. And what the heck is goat cheese?! 

Well, my more mature self is now in love with this sandwich. 

Not only because its delicious, but also because it takes very little prep work and only minutes to cook (grill). And if there is one constant with my recipes, it's easy. The more stupid easy they are, the better. Spending hours in a kitchen cooking a meal that takes minutes to eat has never appealed to me. Do you have any idea how many pages of a book I can read in that same time?! 

Strawberry and Grilled Goat Cheese Sandwich


  • 1 goat cheese log softened (Aldi sells these!)
  • whole grain sliced bread
  • red pepper jelly (Walmart carries this by the regular jelly)
  • fresh sliced strawberries
  • fresh basil leaves (optional)
  • watercress or arugula (optional) 

Spread the goat cheese on one side of the whole grain bread and set aside. Then spread the red pepper jelly on another slice of bread and layer with strawberries, basil leaves, and watercress or arugula. Top this with the goat cheese slice, goat cheese side down of course. 

Cook sandwiches in a lightly greased nonstick pan for 2 - 3 minutes on each side until the bread is just browned. Then, enjoy! 

Strawberry and Grilled Goat Cheese Sandwich

This is a great way to use up all of those strawberries that you picked or that you got for a good deal because the store marked them down. 

So I'm curious, can you list 5 foods that you love now, but hated as a kid? I'll go first....

  • tomatoes
  • mushrooms
  • avocado
  • onion
  • whole grain bread

Like this recipe? Don't forget to pin it on Pinterest! 

Recipe adapted from Southern Living Home Cooking Basics: A Complete Illustrated Guide to Southern Cooking

Did you know posts like this can be delivered right to your inbox with my daily email newsletter?
Subscribe here!
1.0   Shaina
7/28/2014 9:02:20 AM
Stopping by from the Busy Monday party, thanks for sharing! You totally 100% had me at goat cheese. OMGGGG Yum!
2.0   Cheryl
7/29/2014 6:04:03 AM
My five: onion spinach asparagus sauerkraut enchilladas (not a food, but a dish I hated and now love) This sandwich looks to die for! I found this lovely recipe on the In and Out of the Kitchen link party and thought I’d stop by. I host a recipe link party, The Yuck Stops Here and would love it if you would bring this recipe and any other recipes you love to the party! The party starts tonight (Tuesday) at 8pm ET and can be found on my blog, Hot Momma’s Kitchen Chaos. I hope to see you there! HUGS
3.0   Heather @ Shards of Lavender
7/29/2014 2:56:05 PM
This sandwich looks delicious! I was just looking for another way to use goat cheese and I have a ton of strawberries, so I'll have to try this! I wasn't a picky kid growing up, so I can't think of any food I didn't really like, except for ketchup. I still hate it!
Don’t be shy! Upload your picture here for your own unique Gravatar!
Leave A Comment
Name (Optional):
Email(Required - Not Displayed):
Website (Optional):
Notify me of follow up comments via e-mail:
Security Question:
What is 5 plus 3?